Have you ever sat at a red light and suddenly heard a strange knocking sound coming from your engine? It might sound like a soft tap, a loud bang, or something in between. 

If this happens while your engine is idling (which means the car is on but not moving), it could be a warning sign that something’s wrong. 

But don’t panic! Many of these problems are simple to fix once you know what to look for.

In this guide, we’ll explain step-by-step how to diagnose a knocking sound in your engine while it’s idling. By the end, you’ll have a good idea of what might be causing it—and what to do next.

Engine knocking, also called “pinging” or “detonation,” is a strange sound that comes from your engine. It can be a sharp knock or a soft rattle. 

Knocking can happen when parts inside the engine don’t work the way they should. If you hear it when your car is idling, it means the issue may show up even when the engine isn’t under much stress.

Engine knocking can be caused by a variety of things—some are small and easy to fix, while others are more serious. That’s why it’s important to figure out what’s going on as soon as you hear the noise.

Your ears are the first tools you should use. Pay close attention to how the sound behaves.

• Where is it coming from? Try to figure out if the sound is from the top, bottom, front, or back of the engine.
• What does it sound like? Is it a sharp metallic clunk or a dull thumping?
• How often does it happen? Is the knocking steady, or does it come and go?

If the noise happens only while idling and disappears when you speed up, it might point to specific engine parts that only rattle or loosen at lower engine speeds. Taking notes or even recording the sound with your phone can help later if you decide to visit a mechanic.

Low or dirty engine oil is one of the most common reasons for engine knocking. Your engine relies on clean oil to keep its parts moving smoothly. 

If the oil level is too low or if the oil is old and dirty, the parts inside the engine can rub against each other and cause knocking.

• Make sure your car is parked on a level surface.
• Turn off the engine and wait about 10 minutes.
• Pull out the oil dipstick, wipe it clean, and insert it again.
• Pull it out again and look at the oil level.
• Also, check the oil’s color. If it’s black and gritty, it’s time for an oil change.

Fix: If the oil is low, top it off. If it’s dirty, change it. Using the wrong oil type (like 5W-30 instead of 10W-30) can also cause problems, so check your owner’s manual.

Spark plugs are small parts that light the fuel in your engine. If they are worn out or dirty, they can misfire. Misfiring causes the air-fuel mixture to ignite at the wrong time, which leads to knocking sounds.

• Let the engine cool completely.
• Remove each spark plug using a spark plug socket.
• Look for damage, oil, or heavy carbon buildup.
• Compare them to images online that show good vs. bad spark plugs.

Fix: If you see damage or wear, replace them. Spark plugs are cheap and can greatly improve how your engine runs.

Sometimes the knocking sound isn’t coming from inside the engine—it could be from a loose part around it.

Common culprits:

• Heat shields
• Exhaust components
• Brackets or clamps

• With the engine off, gently tap around parts under the hood.
• Try wiggling the exhaust pipes and metal covers.
• Listen for rattling or metal clinking.

Fix: Tighten any loose parts with a socket wrench or screwdriver. If a part is broken or rusted, you might need to replace it.

Engine mounts keep the engine in place and help absorb vibrations. If one breaks or wears out, your engine might shake when idling, which can lead to knocking noises.

• Start your engine with the hood open.
• Have someone sit in the car with their foot on the brake.
• Watch the engine while they shift from Park to Drive and back.
• If the engine jumps or moves a lot, your mounts might be damaged.

Fix: This is a job best left to a mechanic, but it’s important to diagnose it early to avoid more damage.

Rod knock is one of the more serious problems. It happens when the bearings that hold the connecting rods inside your engine wear out. This causes the rods to knock against the crankshaft.

• Deep, loud knocking from the bottom of the engine
• Gets louder when you press the gas pedal
• Won’t go away with an oil change

Fix: Unfortunately, rod knock usually means your engine needs a major repair or rebuild. If you think this is the issue, stop driving and call a professional right away.

Timing makes sure everything in the engine happens at the right moment. If the timing is off, it can cause early or late ignition, leading to engine knock.

• The car struggles to start
• Poor gas mileage
• Knocking when idling and driving

Fix: This needs a mechanic to check the timing with special tools. If your timing belt or chain is worn, it may need to be replaced.

Using fuel with the wrong octane rating can also cause knocking. Some engines are designed to run on premium fuel. If you use regular instead, the engine may knock.

• Check your owner’s manual to see what kind of fuel your car needs.
• If you’ve been using lower-quality gas, try filling up with premium for a few tanks and see if the noise goes away.

Modern cars have a computer system that keeps track of problems. If there’s a knocking sound, a warning light might show up—or it might not. Either way, it’s smart to scan your engine for error codes.

• Buy or borrow an OBD2 scanner.
• Plug it into the port under your dashboard.
• Follow the instructions to get codes.
• Search the code online or take it to a mechanic.

These codes can point to things like misfires, sensor failures, or timing issues—all of which can cause knocking.

A knocking sound during idling isn’t something you should ignore. Thankfully, in many cases, the cause is small—like dirty oil, bad spark plugs, or loose parts. 

Use this step-by-step guide to carefully check each possible issue. Start with the easy stuff, like oil and fuel, and work your way up to more complex problems. 

And remember, if the knocking keeps getting louder or deeper, it’s time to visit a mechanic. Catching a problem early can save you from expensive repairs down the road.

The post How to diagnose knocking sound in engine while idling appeared first on Dempsters Quality Car Care.